Son Can’t Claim Parents’ Property Till They Are Alive: Bombay HC – News18

Bombay high court on Wednesday told a man he holds no legal right to claim his parents’ two flats as his “shared household” as long as they are alive, TOI reported. “Your father is alive. Your mother is alive. You have zero interest in your father’s estate. He can sell it. He does not need your permission. Understood?” said Justices Gautam Patel and Madhav Jamdar.

The case regards a son, who sought to intervene in a petition by his mother, along with his two married sisters, to appoint her as the legal guardian of her husband who is in a vegetative state. He has dementia, has had multiple strokes, and has been hospitalised often.

A report by JJ Hospital, dated October 1, 2022, has pointed out that he has had dementia since 2011. He has pneumonitis and bed sores. He is administered oxygen nasally, fed through a Ryles tube, and has a Foley catheter. He has spontaneous eye movements but cannot maintain eye contact, speak, understand, sign or take any decision.

Advertisement

TOI reported that the advocate for the son, who lives at another address, said he has been the de facto guardian of his father for several years. “You (the son) should have come to appoint yourself de jure guardian. You took him once to the doctor? You paid his medical bills?” asked Justice Patel.

The judges, in their March 16 order, noted while the petitioners have annexed a large number of documents showing expenses and bills paid by the mother, there is not one piece of paper cited by him in support of his contention.

The son’s advocate then said although his parents are alive. The fact that he is their son does not make either of their flats a ‘shared household’,” they said.

The son’s advocate then said although his parents are alive, the two flats are his “shared household” and he has a legal right to them. TOI in its report quoted the judgment, which said: “The submission is so ill-founded and illogical that it only needs to be stated to be rejected. In any conceptualisation of succession law for any community or faith, the son can have no right, title, or interest in either of these flats—one in his father’s name and the other in his mother’s name—so long as his parents are alive. The fact that he is their son does not make either of their flats a ‘shared household’.”

Further, the son has “no rights in his father’s flats” and he has “nothing to show that he has ever cared for his father”. The judges rejected the son’s intervention application, saying they don’t need his consent for the order they intend to make. They also rejected his contention that his mother has an alternate remedy to move the committee under the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, adding, “That submission alone shows us his true nature, his utterly heartless and avaricious approach.” Keeping the petition pending, they permitted the mother to operate a joint bank

Read all the Latest News , Breaking News and Ukraine-Russia War Live Updates here.